Monday, March 30, 2015
Conflict in the Islamic World is Driving International Organized Crime
By Neil Thompson (ISN)
Why have so many Muslim states become hotbeds of organized crime? Neil Thompson’s answer looks beyond depressed
economies, faltering dictatorships and human rights abuses. Indeed, he sees too many individuals that have become corrupted
by the countless opportunities that conflict provides.
Whenever a state collapses into civil war or economic anarchy, its organized crime groups find plenty of opportunities
to grow in influence. This was the case in Albania in 1996-1997 when a series of pyramid schemes collapsed the economy. In
the ensuing riots the government collapsed, the army and police disbanded and the mounting unrest allowed protesters to storm
government arms depots. One crowd looted up to 500,000 rifles and other pieces of military equipment from the southern city of Lushnje. The stolen arms were promptly
sold on the black market and the availability of plentiful supplies of cheap weapons and ammunition was a major spark for
the start of war in neighboring Kosovo the following year. By 1999 transnational organized criminal gangs had helped change
the supposedly sacrosanct lines of European borders. It was a seminal moment for a still under-appreciated non-state actor
- globalized transnational criminal networks. The next might be provided by the Islamic world.
On Western Doorsteps
Westerners living in developed countries are often insulated from the reality of modern organized crime’s strength
because the hubs of transnational criminal operations tend to be located in countries with weak economies and fragile state
institutions. Consequently, too many Western analysts continue to see transnational criminal groups as a second tier threat,
and focus instead on more obvious dangers such as militant Islamist networks or state-backed rebels fighting ‘proxy wars’. Yet, wherever state structures are unable to contain them, criminal groups have found spaces to expand and to diversify.
This is as true in the globalized offline world as it is in the virtual spaces of the internet.
From the emergence of Eurasian mafias as ‘mid-wives of capitalism’ in the post-Soviet space to the rise of Somalia’s pirate bands, organized criminal networks have an insidious
ability to surprise the West with their arrival, the forms they assume and the unique challenges they pose to democracy and
peace. Take the case of Mexico, a democratic middle-income country on the border of the world’s strongest military power.
The US-backed war against its drug cartels has raged for almost a decade now and claimed the lives of over one hundred thousand people.
the depressed economies and faltering dictatorships of the greater Middle East are primarily seen as a serious threat to international
and regional security because they have created self-funding networks of violent religious extremists such as the so-called
Islamic State. Another familiar consideration is the gross human rights abuses carried out by the security services of many
regional governments. Yet, this analysis misses a potential third source of destabilization - networks of mafia-like groups
whose roots lie inside state security services and/or the Islamist groups opposing them.
Many already-powerful Middle Eastern state agents have become thoroughly criminalized by the opportunities the chaos of war affords, in a region notorious for impunity. For instance, Egypt’s ex-President
Hosni Mubarak and his sons were released from prison in January 2015, four years after their convictions on a variety of serious criminal charges, including conspiracy
to murder, while in office. Meanwhile much of the revenue for Islamist groups like Islamic State is generated by proceeds
from criminal activities or from taxing criminal groups. Consequently, the consolidation of war economies mean that criminal
networks currently created or sponsored by the state or Islamist groups might well outgrow their origins and original purposes.
The danger here is that these groups will not disappear when a conflict ends. Indeed, historical experience from conflicts
in places like Colombia suggests that they adapt and persist in new forms.
In a globalizing
world, the networking impulses that have created transnational supply chains stretching thousands of miles for contraband
goods are sure to blur the distinctions between state and non-state actor, law enforcer, rebel and criminal. Moreover, the
unsettled end periods of military conflicts are often marked with a crime wave as individuals turn skills learned during war
to private use. With poor economic prospects, a large black market economy and large numbers of guerrillas, paramilitaries,
soldiers and secret policemen looking for new opportunities, the chances of an explosion in organized crime across the Middle
East are high, to say the least. The overall failure of the Arab Spring will also play its part. So will the region’s
youthful population, persistent high unemployment and geographical proximity to the European market. And let’s not forget
about pre-establishment of human-trafficking involving countries like Libya, as well as high levels of corruption and impunity
in the region’s state structures.
also lead to the development of lawless zones that shelter criminal networks - as well as insurgent groups - from law enforcement
activities. According to the Fund for Peace’s (FFP) Fragile States Index 2014, Syria, Libya, Yemen and several other countries with significant Muslim populations fall into the worst categories,
indicating that the state no longer controls all its territory. In others, such as Egypt and Algeria, central authority is
either compromised or very weak. A good example of this is Lebanon's Bekaa Valley, long a source of marijuana to European markets. There are nearly
40,000 outstanding warrants hanging over the heads of Bekaa residents. Yet, by retreating to the northern reaches of the valley
local clans involved in drug farming have managed to defy Lebanon’s ineffective central authorities. In addition, the
Hezbollah leadership has distanced itself from direct leadership of the clans but continues to demand a political, rather
than legal, solution to the problem.
Wars also strengthen
indigenous criminal organizations and weaken the state institutions charged with combating them, as resources are diverted
into fighting insurgencies. Criminal growth can be partly be tracked by the increase of corruption, an inevitable side-effect
of an increase in black market opportunities. Out of 174 nations, Transparency International’s 2014 corruption ratings
rank Yemen at 161, Iraq at 170, Libya at 166 and Syria at 159. Scores in all four countries have fallen since 2012 and all
four are still the scene of armed conflict and political instability.
Indeed, the effects of corruption and insecurity do not remain limited cleanly by borders but spill into neighboring
states. NATO member Turkey has had a long history of oil-fuelled corruption dating back to the 1990s ‘Oil for Food’
UN program. Today Islamic State middlemen sell oil to smugglers, who bribe their way past Turkish gendarmes at the border and sell it to Turkish businessmen. The
black market fuel is then sold onto the Turkish consumer at a fraction of its true worth. These transactions fuel attacks
like the one that killed Saudi General Oudah al-Belawi, commander of border operations in Saudi Arabia’s northern zone in January. Organized
crime in Turkey has therefore facilitated Islamist terrorism on the Saudi border, while Islamic State has helped corrupt to
Turkey’s nascent democracy.
Yet, unlike their European and
Latin American, Italian counterparts, Islamic criminal enterprises have so far attracted little Western attention as an issue separate from terrorism. Nonetheless organized crime is an entrenched part of the political economy of many
Muslim states. For example, an Afghan narcotics boom has already occurred according to the BBC as last year’s opium
harvest reached a record high. The UN valued the 2013 crop at nearly $3bn (£1.86bn), up 50% from 2012. Indeed, cultivation
has been rising since 2010, a reflection of the fact that Afghanistan currently produces more than 80% of the world's
At the opposite end of the Islamic world
are West Africa’s cigarette and cocaine smuggling operations – a very lucrative trade that is dominated by criminalized Islamist networks. These have grown out of the defeated remnants of Algerian jihadist groups, much as
leftist insurgent groups have come to play an important in the drugs trade in Latin America. Interestingly, the jihadist considered
to be at the forefront of these activities, Mokhtar Belmokhtar, was once considered a minor threat and a pragmatist because
his criminal business interests seemed more pressing to him. However, these same interests gave him the means to launch a
devastating attack on the In Amenas gas plant in 2013.
could also be claimed that the persistence of tribal or clan-based identities in parts of the Islamic world can geographically
limit some present criminal operations. For example, as mentioned above, the farming families involved in the marijuana trade
in Lebanon’s Bekaa Valley rarely leave it due to many active warrants for their arrest outside the valley. Yet, just
as the Middle East has already produced several multinational global terrorist networks there might also come a time when
its criminal elements are clearly capable of reaching the same level of development. Meanwhile, the wars affecting the area
have ironically given Middle Eastern criminal groups a larger global diaspora to blend in with and recruit from, facilitating
a growth of operations outside their home countries.
does not just include Western states, some of whom have been criticized for accepting few regional refugees, but also neighboring
Muslim nations. Displaced Syrians now make up a quarter of Lebanon’s population for example. As far back as 2013, a UNHCR report found organized crime networks operating easily in the biggest Syrian refugee camp, Za'atari in Jordan. From Slow Boil to Breaking Point also described how Syrian refugees were paying up to $500 to middlemen to be 'sponsored' by Jordanian citizens.
This entitled them to live outside of the lawless and overcrowded sites they found themselves in – it also represented
another revenue stream for criminal groups. Criminal networks have also begun exploiting Syrian refugees by using them as
drug mules. There has been a large spike in seizures of narcotics in neighboring countries according to the Global Initiative Against Transnational Organized Crime network.
A Grim Outlook
after the start (and apparent collapse) of the Arab Spring, Western headlines still focus on the security threat of revolutionary
Islamist militant groups. But there is no reason to suppose the emergence of factors favorable to the growth of mafia-type
groups in the Islamic world will not also impact upon the West (and the rest) in the future. The toxic combination of broken
economic and political systems, geographical proximity to lucrative European black markets, and a youthful and often traumatized
population is an open invitation to criminal groups already operating in a vacuum of state authority. Similar circumstances
produced generational crime waves of extraordinary virulence in the former Soviet Union and Latin America, which those areas
are still coping with today. It’s entirely possible the Middle East is poised to follow in their footsteps.
article, "A New Enemy - How Conflict in the Islamic World Is Driving International Organized Crime,"
was originally published by the International Relations and Security Network (ISN) on March 20, 2015. ISN is a free public service that provides a wide range of high-quality and
comprehensive products and resources to encourage the exchange of information among international relations and security professionals
worldwide. Reprinted with permission from ISN.
Neil Thompson is researcher for the Institute for Strategic Dialogue and an Editor and contributor to the Future
Foreign Policy Group. He holds an MA in International Relations of East Asia from the University of Durham.