Monday, April 2, 2012
State Department: Security Challenges in Latin America
(Statement of William R. Brownfield,
Assistant Secretary, Bureau of International Narcotics and Law Enforcement Affairs; as prepared)
Chairwoman Granger, Ranking Member Lowey, and distinguished Members of the Subcommittee,
thank you for your invitation to discuss security threats in the Western Hemisphere as well as our efforts to address them.
I am pleased to be with you today.
Let me begin by describing the security
challenge as we see it in the INL Bureau. The persistently high homicide and crime rates throughout Central America, the Caribbean,
and the horrific reports of violence inside Mexico, are symptoms of a broader climate of insecurity throughout the region.
Crime and violence are exacerbated by widespread poverty and unemployment. This is brought into greater focus as criminal
organizations react to the increasing pressure placed on their operations by governments in the region with support from the
United States. These threats undermine and pose profound challenges to good governance, citizen security, and the rule of
law. And absent these fundamental principles, transnational crime, gangs, and other illicit activity can flourish in many
countries, threatening stability and public security.
To counter these
threats, this Administration has advanced an integrated approach of U.S. assistance programs, from traditional prevention,
law enforcement and counternarcotics programs, to anti-corruption, judicial reform, anti-gang, community policing, and corrections
efforts. We are transforming our relationship with foreign partners by moving from the traditional donor-recipient relationship
to one built on equal partnerships that involve shared responsibility and accountability. In each of our initiatives, we work
hand in hand with host nation officials and our partners in the U.S. government, as well as with other donors, such as Colombia,
to strengthen the justice sector institutions, including the judiciary, police and corrections. We coordinate our efforts
with others in the U.S. government who work with communities, civil society, and the private sector, recognizing that security
solutions require a whole of society approach. We have learned that this is the only way to bring long-term stability to countries
threatened by crime and violence. Governments must have the ability, and in fact, have the responsibility to protect their
citizens, to deal with crime and violence so that these issues remain or become law enforcement problems, not national security
threats. This is a long-term strategy that has proven to be effective.
Central America Regional Security Initiative (CARSI), Mérida Initiative, Colombian Strategic Development Initiative
(CSDI), and Caribbean Basin Security Initiatives (CBSI) embrace this approach. They are partnerships in which governments
have collaborated with the United States on the development of joint programs and initiatives that are aimed at protecting
citizens and strengthening the institutions responsible for ensuring citizen safety.
Support for Central America
Today, some 95 percent of the cocaine
from South America destined for the U.S. transits the Central America/Mexico corridor. With these activities comes violence:
Battles between criminal groups for territory and transit routes; clashes between criminals and law enforcement; and violent
crime fuelled by drug consumption, all with the ultimate motive of making a profit. In 2008, anticipating that Mexico's
efforts to challenge cartels would result in the movement of trafficking routes elsewhere, the U.S. government formed a partnership
with Central American nations to enhance their security capacity. CARSI is the resulting program.
Applying our overall strategy and lessons learned through the years, CARSI works to increase the capacity of law
enforcement to combat drug traffickers and provide public security, support prevention efforts targeting at-risk youth and
those living in communities susceptible to crime and recruitment by gangs and traffickers, and strengthen justice sector institutions.
While CARSI prioritizes the so-called "Northern Triangle" countries of El Salvador, Guatemala, and Honduras, where
the levels of crime and violence are most severe and stability most threatened, the program is leveraging our assistance throughout
the region to improve citizen security.
Thanks to support from this Subcommittee
and your Senate colleagues, our government has already committed approximately $231 million in INCLE funding for technical
assistance and training for CARSI between Fiscal Years 2008 and 2011, and, with your approval, we are seeking to dedicate
an additional $85 million for CARSI under the INCLE account in Fiscal Year 2012. Our request for Fiscal Year 2013 continues
our work at $60 million, at an assistance level that matches programming goals for each fiscal year with the actual capacity
of our partners to absorb that assistance.
Our programs are starting to
see results. In a relatively short period of time, crime rates have decreased in municipalities where we are providing targeted
training, equipment, and support. For example, in Lourdes, El Salvador - where INL has a Model Police Precinct - crime rates
have dropped 40 percent over the past year. We have similar model precinct programs in Guatemala and are starting others in
Honduras. Our support to law enforcement is also gaining traction, with specialized vetted units, overall police reform efforts,
and targeted training with our partners from Colombia and Mexico in Central America.
Governments in the region are increasingly recognizing the need to invest in their own security and are passing new
laws on taxes to support investments in citizen security programs, judicially authorized wiretapping programs, extradition,
and asset forfeiture. Change is slow to take hold, however, as corruption and impunity remains widespread. We are working
to accelerate our programs to achieve even more results, including standing up a full-fledged Narcotics Affairs Sections in
San Salvador and Tegucigalpa, and enhancing levels of coordination and planning across the interagency to identify opportunities
and de-conflict programs as necessary.
The regional nature of transnational
crime and the violence it spurs has also prompted an unprecedented international effort to support citizen security efforts
in Central America, including through the Group of Friends of Central America. We are working together with the Central America
Integration System (SICA), joined by common principals, to address our common challenges.
In Mexico we continue to see shocking news
reports of killings and violence; however, the Government of Mexico, with assistance from the United States through the Mérida
Initiative, has had some significant results. The resources you have provided to the INL Bureau, approximately $1.1 billion
in INCLE funds for Mérida since its inception, have helped the Government of Mexico, together with its United States
partner departments and agencies, to continue turning the tables on the cartels. Funds appropriated in Fiscal Year 2012, approximately
$249 million, along with our request for Fiscal Year 2013, $199 million, will ensure continued and sustainable progress. Through
bilateral law enforcement cooperation, 47 high value targets have been arrested or removed in Mexico, including 23 of Mexico's
top 37 most wanted criminals, since December 2009. This aggressive and coordinated approach to dismantle and disrupt the drug
cartels has included an institutional focus on all elements of the justice sector and civil society. The Government of Mexico,
through our Mérida Initiative is transforming Mexico's security forces and has strengthened Mexican government
institutions in order to confront trafficking organizations and associated crime, and maintain public trust and citizen security.
Through the Mérida Initiative, the mobility of Mexico's security forces has increased
significantly. Thanks to your support, the United States has already delivered eight Bell helicopters to Mexico's Army
(SEDENA), three Black Hawk helicopters to Mexico's Navy (SEMAR), and four Black Hawk helicopters to Mexico's Secretariat
of Public Security (SSP) and its Federal Police. As a practical example of the initiative's impact, Mérida provided
Black Hawks were responsible for enabling Mexico's high profile operations against the La Familia cartel in Michoacán
in December 2010, and another operation against Los Zetas in Nuevo Leon in September 2011. Neither of these operations would
have been possible without the air mobility provided and well trained Mexican personnel traveling onboard.
In another example, Mérida Initiative training, provided through U.S. agency implementers,
has reached more than 52,000 federal police, justice sector officials, and state police officials providing lessons on leadership,
accountability, and management. As a result of our professionalization training, and the Government of Mexico's revolutionary
reforms, the new cadre of security officers and officials is more impervious to coercion and corruption by transnational criminals
and the federal government in Mexico now has its own polygraph capacity to vet personnel through two certified federal and
15 state polygraph centers.
The Mérida Initiative has also illustrated
the importance of syncing our assistance in equipment and training for the government of Mexico with programs that enable
Mexican communities to work more closely with government entities to improve their security. We have found that when material
resources, training, and community programs complement each other, the outcome is more successful and more sustainable. Through
one Mérida program, for example, our partners at USAID have delivered over 40 small grants to nongovernmental organizations
that have resulted in programs for at-risk youth and other programs that reduce violence against women, improve mental health,
strengthen community cohesion, and improve education. Another program through Mérida has provided classroom lessons
on the culture of lawfulness and ethics to more than 600,000 students and 14,000 teachers, in some 7,000 separate schools
located in 24 Mexican States.
As is the case in other parts of the hemisphere,
our strategy through Mérida was not singularly focused on dismantling the cartels, but rather a long term institution
building strategy in our partnership with the Government of Mexico.
An Exporter of Regional Security
Best practices learned over decades in
Colombia have informed our overall hemispheric strategy. As a follow-on to Plan Colombia we have continued our partnership
with the Government of Colombia to fortify the gains made over the past decade. We developed a program called the Colombia
Strategic Development Initiative (CSDI), which supports the Colombian Government's National Consolidation Plan. Today,
CSDI provides for civilian institution building, rule of law, and alternative development programs, along with security and
counternarcotics efforts in those areas where poverty, violence, and illicit cultivation or drug trafficking persist and have
historically converged. We are supporting these endeavors with significantly reduced resource levels; however, continued resources
will be needed to sustain and consolidate our gains.
For example, our
Fiscal Year 2013 request represents more than an $18 million reduction from our Fiscal Year 2012 INCLE enacted, and a $62
million reduction from Fiscal Year 2011 INCLE enacted. We've worked closely with our Colombian partners to ensure that
this is not misinterpreted as a reduction in priority or partnership, but rather the appropriate evolution of our joint efforts
-- where we once led assistance efforts to now supporting Colombia's sustainment and nationalization of those efforts.
Our efforts in Colombia are paying dividends regionally as well. With the capacity that the
Government of Colombia built over the years, Colombia is now bolstering efforts to address similar security concerns elsewhere
in the region. Colombia today is no longer just a recipient of security assistance but an exporter of it. Since 2009, the
Colombian National Police (CNP), our closest partner in promoting citizen security throughout the region, has trained some
10,000 police from across Latin America in areas such as criminal investigation skills, personal protection, and anti-kidnapping
among other critical law enforcement disciplines. Colombia's participation in improving security and reducing instability
throughout the hemisphere by providing needed training is an enormous return on our investment in that country, and is precisely
the type of regional approach to security promoted by Secretary Clinton. This is a positive trend, one which we firmly believe
will continue with additional partners and with ownership by governments of the region.
Support for Caribbean Nations
The deleterious effects of drug
smuggling, gangs and violent crime are also adversely affecting many countries in the Caribbean, including transnational criminals
returning in a limited nature to air, maritime, and terrestrial routes in the Caribbean to traffic illicit products. Accordingly,
in 2009, President Obama launched the Caribbean Basin Security Initiative, which like our other initiatives, is a collaborative
endeavor undertaken in partnership with various United States departments and agencies, as well as the nations in the region.
Citizen security is the single most important issue confronting the Caribbean as narcotics-driven
crime and violence have reached epidemic proportions, threatening the safety and security of United States and Caribbean citizens
CBSI, like each of our other major partnerships, aims to increase
stability and improve security, and applies a whole of government approach to the challenges confronting Caribbean nations.
We have committed $48 million in INCLE funds during the first two years of CBSI for programs and equipment to support our
Caribbean partners, and we expect to commit an additional $30 million in INCLE funds for Fiscal Year 2012, with your support.
Our Fiscal Year 2013 INCLE request of $21 million will allow us to continue to support programs
that strengthen Caribbean partner nation capabilities in the areas of maritime security, law enforcement, information sharing,
border and migration control, transnational crime, and criminal justice.
our programs seek to increase regional cooperation of our Caribbean partners to share law enforcement data, including ballistics
imaging, airport passenger manifests, and fingerprinting, through software and training. Technical assistance will increase
the ability of our partners to combat financial crimes and money laundering, while equipment and training for law enforcement
personnel target narcotics trafficking on land and sea. These efforts seek to strengthen national and regional security systems
throughout the Caribbean before the threats of illicit trafficking and transnational crime worsen.
* * *
Madam Chairwoman, Ranking Member Lowey, I have focused
my prepared remarks today on the programs we are administering to support our partners in the Western Hemisphere for a reason.
As you know well, the challenges to secure and safe societies in the hemisphere are vast, and insecure societies host the
majority of criminals whose crimes directly threaten our nation's security. We recognize that there is no easy fix for
these problems, and we will continue to evaluate our progress and adjust our approaches as these complex and dynamic threats
evolve. We focus largely on regional programs because they provide the platform for several nations to coordinate their strategy
and ensure a unified capability to addressing their shared challenges. Regional programs also allow us to multiply the impact
and value of our assistance by syncing up with the contributions made by each government in the region. While these programs
represent our major mechanisms for addressing threats to security in the Western Hemisphere, they are by no means our only
mechanisms. We have ongoing bilateral programs - some robust like in Peru and Haiti, and some less so, in other countries
in the hemisphere.
In Peru for example, where our bilateral counternarcotics
relationship has been reinvigorated by an eager and supportive administration there, we have programs to increase capacity
of law enforcement and programs to support a significant coca eradication effort. This is going to be an important area for
us to watch closely, and I look forward to further discussions with the Subcommittee as our partnership there continues to
evolve. And in Haiti, where perhaps the absence of strong and capable government institutions had been the most striking in
the Western Hemisphere, INL supports programs to improve the capacity of law enforcement as well as the judicial sector. It
is also worth noting that we are working very diligently to engage our friends in the region, particularly those with recognized
competency in particular areas, to strengthen the capacity of not just others countries within the Western Hemisphere, but
across the globe.
Madam Chairwoman, Ranking Member Lowey, thank you very
much for the opportunity to discuss and share with you the work we are doing to address these challenging threats to the security
of the people of the Western Hemisphere. I look forward to your questions.
Testimony of William R. Brownfield, Assistant Secretary, Bureau of International Narcotics
and Law Enforcement Affairs, U.S. Department of State, before the Subcommittee on State, Foreign Operations, and Related Programs
of the House Appropriations Committee, Washington, D.C., Mar. 29, 2012