Monday, March 3, 2008
US
& Mexican Activists Target Merida Initiative, Trade Pacts
Frontera NorteSur
Promising $1.4 billion in new funding
to fight the drug war over the next three years, the Bush White House's Merida Initiative is a strategic cornerstone of the
outgoing administration's envisioned future relationship with Mexico and Central America. Thomas Shannon, US Assistant Secretary
of State for Western Hemisphere Affairs has called the assistance package a "new paradigm" of regional security cooperation.
Still
awaiting approval by the US Congress, the Merida Initiative, which some compare with Plan Colombia, would significantly
increase assistance to the Mexican military, aid Mexico with high-tech communications and surveillance equipment, and increase
the training of Mexican security forces. According to US State Department anti-narcotics official David Johnson, Washington
trained 4,627 Mexican police in 2007, and plans to train an additional 5,800 in 2008.
The Merida Initiative [was] expected
to be a major topic of discussion when US Department of Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff and Mexican Interior
Minister Juan Camilo Mauriņo meet in Los Cabos, Baja California Sur, [last] week.
Politically, the Merida Initiative
is under consideration at a time when the Mexican army, the principal force in President Felipe Calderon's offensive against
organized crime, is coming under renewed fire for alleged human rights abuses. Two incidents reported in northern Tamaulipas
state this month exemplify the mounting controversy.
In the first case, hundreds of residents of the border city of
Reynosa held a protest [in February] against the shooting death of Sergio Meza by Mexican soldiers in Matamoros. Meza and
his brother-in-law, US citizen and Reynosa resident Jose Antonio Barbosa, reportedly attempted to evade a Mexican army patrol
because they had been drinking and using illegal drugs. The National Human Rights Commission opened an investigation of the
shooting.
In the second incident, Guadalupe Barbosa Cruz, a Roman Catholic priest from San Fernando, Tamaulipas, was
allegedly beaten along with three associates by soldiers at an army checkpoint. Matamoros Bishop Faustino Armendariz Jimenez
charged that the priest and his companions were also robbed of their personal possessions.
According to the Matamoros
Diocese, the beatings went on "for a long time" until soldiers realized that one of the men in their custody was a priest.
The incident drew a condemnation from the Mexican Episcopal Conference: "The fight against organized crime does not justify
crimes against innocent citizens by those who should be looking out for their safety."
In the United States, meanwhile,
labor and human rights activists demand that the Bush administration's proposed security aid program for Mexico and Central
America be rejected outright or at least have stringent rights guarantees placed on it.
Helping galvanize the opposition
is the still-unpunished murder of US journalist Brad Will in Oaxaca during the 2006 uprising against the state government
of Ulises Ruiz. Although Mexican police were clearly identified in photos and by witnesses as the shooters who killed Will,
none of the perpetrators have been arrested for the crime. Twice since last fall the activist group Friends of Brad Will has
disrupted US congressional hearings on the Merida Initiative.
Although some of Will's supporters were removed from
the sessions by police, the group took credit for broadening the security debate to encompass human rights issues. On Friday,
February 23, Friends of Brad Will helped organize a forum and cultural event on the Merida Initiative at the City University
of New York. Last week, the group also relayed its concerns to New York Senator Charles Schumer.
Another big issue
spurring opposition to the Merida Initiative is the Mexican government's breaking of a strike over safety conditions at the
Cananea copper mine near the Arizona border last month. Armed with an order from the country's Labor Ministry that declared
the strike illegal, Mexican federal police – reportedly aided by soldiers – forcibly removed strikers from the
Grupo Mexico-owned mine. However, the Mexican Union of Mine, Metal and Allied Workers, which is led by the exiled Napoleon
Gomez, quickly won a legal victory when a court ruled the strike was indeed legal.
An important ally of the Mexican
miners, the United Steelworkers (USW) of the United States and Canada, demanded this month that the Merida Initiative be suspended
until US congressional hearings are held on the Cananea strike. In mid-February, a group of USW and Mexican union leaders
met with members of the House Foreign Affairs Committee and the Hispanic Caucus on Capitol Hill.
"Mexico cannot be
permitted to violate the rights of workers with impunity under the pretext of securing the borders and combating drug trafficking,"
said USW President Leo Gerard.
On their Washington visit, Mexican labor activists also protested the cancelled recovery
of the bodies of 63 miners killed in the 2006 Pasta de Conchos explosion, and the shooting deaths of two workers by police
at Lazaro Cardenas steel works in Michoacan also in 2006.
"We want to make sure that in the bilateral relationship
between Mexico and the United States, where issues such as the Merida Initiative are on the table, money won't be used against
the people of Mexico and the workers, like what happened at Lazaro Cardenas," said Jose Luis Hernandez, a leader of Gomez's
union from Coahuila state.
The USW's demands surrounding the Merida Initiative should be viewed as part of a bigger
challenge that the union is launching against other existing or proposed international agreements. For instance, the USW is
lobbying the US Congress to reject the proposed US-Colombia free trade agreement due to massive labor and human rights violations
allegedly committed by the Colombian government. According to the USW, 2,283 labor leaders have been killed in Colombia since
1991; more than four hundred of the murders have occurred during the six-year-old administration of current President Alvaro
Uribe.
In a recent statement, the USW criticized the Uribe government`s Peace and Justice Law for opening the legal
door to light prison sentences for paramilitary gunmen convicted of killing trade unionists. "In the meantime, death threats
against trade unionists in Colombia persist, with more than 200 occurring last year," the union said.
The USW formed
part of a delegation of international trade unionists from North America, the United Kingdom and Ireland that traveled to
Colombia to meet with Colombian union and political leaders [last] month. Claiming 850,000 members in the US and Canada, the
USW is certain to have an influential voice during a US election year, especially one in which Democratic candidates Barack
Obama and Hillary Clinton are stating that trade agreements, including the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), deserve
a second look.
Not all of the activists' fire is directed at governments to the south. Some US-based immigrant rights
activists, for example, are urging the administration of Mexican President Felipe Calderon to forego signing any new security,
anti-drug or economic development agreements with Washington until the United States implements an immigration reform that
benefits undocumented workers and their families.
On his US tour [last] month, President Calderon was read a letter
from activist Flor Crisostomo that proposed conditioning Mexico-US cooperation on a satisfactory resolution of the immigration
question. Taking the torch from Elvira Arellano, Crisostomo, an undocumented immigrant, is defying deportation from the sanctuary
of a Methodist church in Chicago, Illinois. In her letter, Crisostomo also urged Calderon to revisit NAFTA.
"We call
on the Mexican government to renegotiate NAFTA, because for 14 years it has been the principal propeller of migration and
the separation of families in Mexico," Crisostomo wrote the Mexican president. "And we are seen and treated like criminals
in this country," she added.
Taken together, the emerging waves of activism that link trade and security agreements
to outstanding immigration, labor and human rights issues are not all that surprising in view of the parameters which were
laid down for NAFTA and other bilateral agreements between Mexico and the US. In the run-up to NAFTA more than 15 years ago,
labor and human rights advocates unsuccessfully appealed for the inclusion of strong human rights and immigration provisions
in the trade pact. But unlike the European Union's trade regime, which includes democratic, human rights and immigration guarantees,
broader social concerns were largely excluded from the deal hatched by NAFTA's negotiators.
Sources: Enlineadirecta.info,
February 19, 2008. Article by Hugo Reyna. Proceso/Apro, February 16, 2008. Article by Jose Gil Olmos. Cimacnoticias.com, February
13, 2008. La Jornada, November 15, 2007; February 14, 19 and 21, 2008. Articles by David Brooks, Jose Antonio Roman and editorial
staff. United Steelworkers, February 11, 2008. Press statement. Friendsofbradwill.org.
——————————
Frontera
NorteSur (FNS)
Center for Latin American and Border Studies
New Mexico State University
Las Cruces, New Mexico
——————————
(Reprinted with authorization
from Frontera NorteSur, a free, on-line, U.S.-Mexico border news source. FNS can be found at http://frontera.nmsu.edu/)
Translation FNS
